17 Comments
User's avatar
Matthew Kirtley's avatar

>The error that we are led towards by making Christianity a central part of our political movement’s identity — and therefore, our vision for a national identity — is assigning an element of universality to the citizenry of the nation.

I think you've hit nail on head. I think the central political objective of the British right should be to reject the logic of universalism wholesale.

As cliche as it is to quote De Maistre, I always have enjoyed this one (from Considerations on France):

“Now, there is no such thing as ‘man’ in this world. In my life I have seen Frenchmen, Italians, Russians, and so on. I even know, thanks to Montesquieu, that one can be Persian. But as for man, I declare I’ve never encountered him.”

User's avatar
Comment deleted
Nov 15, 2025
Comment deleted
MA's avatar

If Christianity is such an inherently left wing religion, why is it that Apartheid South Africa had the Old Testament as part of its ideological foundation? If Christianity is inherently a universalist hippy religion, why was it that the Prime Minister of South Africa who codified Apartheid was a reverend in the Dutch Reformed Church with a doctorate in Divinity? Why is it that the most militant defenders of British nationalism have been the Protestants of Northern Ireland, who have fought against the Soviet backed terrorists of the IRA and against mass immigration? Also, De Maistre was a devout Catholic who believed that political authority should be derived from religion. This is not me making an argument for making Christianity an integral part of the British Right, but more that I take umbrage with historically illiterate gibberish. I may be an atheist who supports a secular Right, but I am still able to recognise that Christianity is not inherently left wing or right wing.

True European's avatar

Loyalists/Unionists in Northern Ireland and the tiny Orania cohort are essentially relics from the European religious wars of the 16th and 17th centuries with Catholics and Catholicism the only sworn enemy. The IRA received tonnes of weapons from Colonel Gadaffis Libya but their greatest source of political and moral support came from the US Democrats. Republican/Nationalist parties Sinn Fein/SDLP in Northern Ireland support open borders primarily because it's seen as diluting Unionism. While for their counterparts down south because it's an unspoken quid pro quo for their continuing corporate tax haven status. Those political parties in the Republic of Ireland that gleefully displayed to the world how post Catholic they were by voting in referenda in favour of homosexual marriage in 2015 and abortion in 2018.When Protestants cease voting Unionist/Loyalist they tend to become Alliance party voters the equivalent of Liberal Democrats in NI.

Many of the 17th century Dutch Protestants who emigrated to South Africa could only cope with the black Africans that they encountered by believing that they had been "cursed by god ".

MA's avatar

I am not sure why you are saying that Orania is a relic of the European religious wars, given that their main enemy are the ANC and not Catholics. With the Loyalists/Unionists, I agree with you to some extent, but they are also some of the most militant people in the fight against immigration in the UK. There have been numerous riots against immigration across Northern Ireland involving Loyalists or lead by Loyalists. There is also a long history of co-operation between the Loyalists in Northern Ireland and the UK nationalist Right, including Combat 18.

Regarding the OIRA and the PIRA, I think it is also worth noting that they were also part of the international Soviet terrorist network. They received weapons from the Soviets in August 1972 according to the Mitrokhin Archive records. The PIRA also received training at camps in Libya run by the Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine whose operations director, Wadi Haddad, was a KGB agent. They were also receiving training at PLO camps in Syrian-occupied areas of Lebanon. The PLO had effectively become a part of the Soviet terror network as well by the 70’s, and the Syrians were acting as a satellite in the Middle East through which the Soviets could direct their terrorist network. The IRA also helped set up a bomb making school in Luanda for the ANC, where the East German Stasi also trained the ANC in torture techniques.

With the Libyan arms shipments, some of those cases are better described as the Libyans acting as middle-men for the Soviets. For example, the October 1986 shipment of Semtex and other weapons originated from communist Czechoslovakia and Libya acted as a middleman. Libya at the time also needs to be thought of more as a Soviet satellite, since I believe the Soviets had a number of “military advisors” there.

With the above in mind, I think it is better to say that Sinn Fein and the IRA support open borders more due to an actual deep ideological commitment to socialism than trying to dilute Loyalism.

User's avatar
Comment deleted
Nov 15, 2025
Comment deleted
MA's avatar

Are you being sarcastic or openly admitting error? Again, I admit that there are lots of left wing idiots in the various churches who are enabling our ethnic replacement, but these people would be doing the same if they were atheists. Many of those who support ethnic replacement within the church are also those who are openly against key laws of the Bible (e.g. the ban on women priests and the ban against homosexuality). I am not arguing for Christianity to be an essential part of any political platform, but rather that opposition to it is pointless. Whether someone is Christian or not, if they believe in mass deportations, reversing current demographic trends, and enabling economic growth they are fine by me.

Sally Free's avatar

My teen went through a phase of wanting a cross necklace and making the sign of the cross and saying "god bless" I'm pretty sure he was influenced mostly by his Syrian friend who makes a point of wearing a large cross on the outside of his shirt, but I have seen a surge in pro Christian TikToks.

The thing I noticed with his peers was a fad-like, superficial interest in Christianity (and Islam). Donning cross necklaces, putting cross in bio temporarily etc. But that's as far as it went. And it was more trendy last year and at the beginning of the year than it is now, and it's died down. Even become a bit cringe.

Through my son I'm familiar with a slightly older local lad (white, English) who is a bit of a TikTok personality who has become a Muslim but in a similarly surface level way e.g. saying "Inshallah" a lot and comparing non religious girls to good virgin girls (he is adamant he's getting a virgin Muslim girl though I doubt any with a brain will let their daughter near him) and performatively praying outside because it's time to pray now. He comes across as a lost working class soul, has a lot of ghetto mannerisms like walking with a hand down his trousers and makes those gang signs with his hands. My son thinks he's cool for now. For anyone who hasn't got teens or pre-teens they all say "Wallahi" atm, I nearly go insane from the amount of "wallahi bruv" I hear. But I also go insane from hearing about "big batty bunda" and rapping about drug dealing and stabbing people.

The Christian revival feels a little forced like a band-aid solution to the problems caused by mass migration and how it's changing us.

I'm increasingly suspicious when media personalities say Islam is the primary problem. It is a huge problem but to me it isn't the main one. The odd emergence of loads of Christians in media who have gone cuckoo with American style proclamations of Christ is King has, if anything, put me off Christianity. Are they all like this? It irritates me so intensely that I almost want to defend Muslims. They seem to think it's better to be ethnically mixed with African Christians than to protect an English non Christian demographic. If that's the case then the right needs to reconsider its alliances.

When I see things online like brown/black Christians or sikh "Christian allies" on the right take the piss out of English who are skeptical of a Christian revival or who are Muslim converts. It feels like someone is encroaching on my people and I really don't like it, even if I generally agree with the Christian. Again, it drives me away from Christianity. As do all of the "Thank God for Immigrants" posters.

My ultimate concern is that our homeland is being given away to foreigners and if we are atheist, Christian, Buddhist, pagan or whatever is secondary to that concern. But apparently not everyone feels that way and we must return to Christ the King in a multiracial orgy? It all feels very American.

Coldfield's avatar

This is true in my experience. I started going to church because I wanted to feel something familiar and homely. However, my closest church is dominated by Indians, Africans and South-east Asians. Brits are 15 - 20% of attendees. So in the end going to church felt more culturally dislocating than not going.

WanderingDalesman's avatar

I thank you for your article. I was amazed and also unsurprised by the amount of people taken in by this report. It is a sad fact that many social media Christians are grifters who will hype up anything.

I left Cambridge 20 years ago and I know from return visits and from college stuff that it is a lot more diverse nowadays. When I was there, the student union said there were more students with Black and Brown as their surnames than there were black and brown students. Very different now.

Keith's avatar

Very good article. I was just wondering today if Ayaan Hirsi Ali is an outlier or whether there is a larger trend of intellectuals becoming Christians. Bo Winegard and Alex Kaschuta seem newly interested in the social benefits of Christianity and a skepticism towards creating a healthy secular society.

I'd love to know why you are a Christian. Tradition? Belief in the literal truth of the bible? Poetry and myth? Good basis for a healthy society?

User's avatar
Comment deleted
Nov 15, 2025
Comment deleted
Keith's avatar

I don't know what hylomorphism is. I'm not even sure how classical theism differs from what I suppose must be different kinds of theism.

Why do philosophers still debate philosophy if Christianity has already cleared up all philosophical problems? Might they, perhaps, disagree with you?

Peter Leach's avatar

Thank you for this, a thought-provoking post.

The ONS section could be sharpened, though. In particular it is not very convincing to label Moss Side in Birmingham (35%+ Black) as "a Somali community" (<2% Somali).

notol's avatar

On that point, the statistic of "2% Somali" refers to people who selected Somali as their primary and only national identity. This differs from the "35% black" statistic which has got to do with ethnic, rather than national, identity. On the 2021 census, one can pick more than one national identity which is specified to the level of (obviously) nations. However, one can only pick one of 4 or 5 ethnic identities (white, black, MENA, east asian, etc.). What the 2% Somali stat indicates is not, therefore, that 2% of people in Moss Side are Somali, but that 2% identify as Somali nationals only. There are likely far more Somalis in Moss Side who identify as Somali + British or just British or English. Nothing is stopping them from doing this. I agree the ONS section was not the most statistically rigorous, however this apparent statistical disparity can be explained in line with the author's argument. The 2% Somali statistic therefore heavily indicates that Moss Side is a majority Somali community.

Stephen Webb's avatar

This Catholic Truth Society event hints at the same trend, praising the diversity that immigrants are bringing in. https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=09dMGpmQVow