I’m a Reform UK politician, and I’ve just been banned from speaking in Wales’ Parliament for talking about demographic change (specifically, the prospect of White British people becoming a minority in Great Britain). I want to talk about how I arrived at the decision to talk about that topic.
The most interesting idea I’ve ever heard is that dialogue with one’s conscience is analogous to dialogue with God. Each of us has within our own head a sense of what we ought and ought not to be doing. That sense has been articulated as a triune God in the Christian tradition, and it’s been conceptualised as a conscience in the work done by post-Enlightenment psychologists. I think there’s a great deal of utility in understanding how, in so many ways, they are the same thing.
And what’s absolutely fascinating, and thrilling, is that you can engage with it, in your own mind. You can ask yourself what you ought to do today, and your own mind will produce an answer for you. And it will very often be an answer that you don’t want to hear. For example, if you need to do your maths homework, no matter how much you might loathe it, your conscience will always tell you so.
Why is that? What does your conscience know that ‘you’ don’t? Why does it have a view of its own, often at odds with ‘yours’? Why does it seemingly understand all of your moral obligations, and what is best for you, better than you do yourself?
It’s capable of assessing any situation you find yourself in, synthesising the unthinkably vast quantities of data that constitute all the information you hold in your own mind, and then plotting a course of action to proceed in that situation optimally based on the information it holds. The brilliance and complexity of that process cannot be overstated. It is the first and foremost wonder of the world. A guide on how to navigate any situation, how to make the most of your life, how to avoid meaningless pain and experience a maximally meaningful life, despite the hardship that might entail.
I speak to my conscience by asking it questions of a moral nature. I don’t ask it what 1873 x 1837 is, because it doesn’t know. But it does know what my moral obligations are and it does know how to interpret the world around me using them. I frequently ask, ‘what should I do?’ and, provided I’m sat in a quiet room where I can think clearly, an answer will immediately spring to mind. Invariably it will be something that I’m reluctant to do for any number of reasons, not least because I’m lazy, and shy, and prideful.
But when I succeed in doing as it prompts me, my days are filled with meaning. I progress towards the goals that matter to me most deeply, I avoid doing things which set my life on an unhappy trajectory, I set myself up for success, I avoid short-term pleasure at the expense of long-term fulfilment, and I become stronger: more capable of dealing with the inevitable trials that befall all of us eventually. I live more bravely and more wisely. It benefits me in every conceivable way, not least in my relationships with other people.
I use the above in combination with a conscious attempt to be reflexively honest about things. I came to the conclusion that honesty was mankind’s primary virtue by means of Christianity, though I no longer explicitly identify as religious, hoping that I’ve separated the baby of its wisdom from the bathwater of the modern-day church. Christians are called by scripture to act ‘perfectly’: to embody every virtue simultaneously all the time. And I wondered how one would go about balancing patience and justice, compassion and personal responsibility, courage and prudence. I came to the conclusion that one would be able to act virtuously in all circumstances if one were completely honest. Christ’s patience might come to an end to make way for justice, his compassion might give way to the encouragement of personal responsibility, his courage might be tempered by prudence, but his honesty would never be corrupted by deceit. Virtue cannot contradict truth. If you’re wondering how to be patient, or just, or loyal, then be honest.
Again, I frequently fall short of the standards I set for myself. If you are looking for someone who practices what he preaches with perfection, I am not him. But I have avoided much pain and confusion in my life by telling the truth about issues before they get out of hand.
So it was with these practices in mind that I asked my conscience what I should raise in the Welsh Parliament on Monday. I sighed at its reply, because I knew that it would be difficult, and then I did as it suggested. The demographic replacement of White British people in the UK is the defining issue of our times, an irreversible transformation which is already well underway, and yet there is little reward available for those who seek to commence this most difficult conversation. Perhaps, then, it is not surprising that this is where my conscience led me. If something is true and important, you should say it, and let the chips fall where they may.
All hell broke loose. I was banned from speaking in the chamber, and my words provoked a national debate online and even in Westminster.
Britain’s culture is best perpetuated by native Brits. We suffer no temptation to split our loyalties, we are the descendants of those who created it in the first place, and we literally know no other way of doing things. Anyone, of any race, can (to a high degree if not completely) adopt our habits, learn to live as we do, become our friends and our neighbours, and join our national community. Members of my own party provide fine examples. Yet this process takes time, effort, and sincerity. When a person arrives in Britain for economic reasons, without any particular love for our ways, and when their identification as British goes no further than their belief in their right to remain here, any discussion of integration becomes ridiculous. Holding a British passport alone does not make one British in the sense we might care about, nor does mere self-identification as such (much as a man identifying as a woman is not female). That is true even if we accept that Britishness is not exclusively defined in ethnic terms: whether someone’s habits, attachments, and perspectives reflect our own is a question of fact which does not depend on their identity. Identification must be mutual: if the majority of the host nation does not recognise you as one of their own, your identity means little, and we retain the right to be honest in our assessment.
We must also recognise that, even to the extent it is possible, assimilation is never perfect. If someone moves to the UK and becomes 80% ‘British’ (whatever that might look like in practice), and then a second person moves here and is assimilated by the first, becoming 80% as ‘British’ as them (not even through any fault of their own; assimilation is hard), and then they help assimilate a third person who becomes 80% as ‘British’ as them, then the third person will only be 51.2% as ‘British’ as a native Brit. Rates of immigration therefore matter enormously, as does the concentration of migrants in certain localities. Work by Garett Jones in his book ‘The Culture Transplant’ illustrates how difficult cultural assimilation can be, with second- and third-generation immigrants actually becoming less like those in their host nation over time than their first generation parents.
My country is precious to me, and I’m not willing to see it disappear in all but name and location in front of my very eyes because I was unwilling to have difficult conversations. I’ve been banned from contributing to that conversation in Wales’ Parliament for now, but I hope to have in some small way made a real difference to national discourse over the past week. At some point, the people native to Great Britain will have to decide whether or not they are comfortable becoming a minority in their ancestral homeland. That is not a decision that should be taken lightly. It is not a decision that the people of this nation should have made for them by cowardly politicians concerned about disapproving comments on social media. It should be talked about, at length, by those of us lucky enough to have been tasked with the leadership of this great nation.
I come to a decision about what I’m going to talk about with very careful thought and consideration. When I write out my contributions, I go through them line by line to make sure that I can stand by each word and sentence. I then summon as much courage as I can to try and deliver it well, and hope for the best. Any conversation about the demographic future of this nation should follow that template: carefully say the bravest and most important thing you find yourself prompted to say by your conscience. If we can all manage that, and extend grace to one another when we do so imperfectly, then maybe, just maybe, we can plot a course through the coming decades that will see us arrive happily on the other side.
This article was written by Joe Martin, Reform UK Member of the Senedd for Caerdydd Penarth.
Have a pitch? Send it to submissions@pimlicojournal.co.uk.
If you enjoyed this article, please consider subscribing. If you are already subscribed, why not upgrade to a paid subscription?

Great, just don't take any rubles.