The news, which in the past came to us by print, then the radio, then the television, now comes to us by podcasts, through which millions of Britons get their news and, therefore, their opinions. The most popular news podcast in Britain is The Rest Is Politics. It is downloaded approximately 630,000 times a week. It is not only the number one politics podcast and number one news podcast in Britain, it is the top politics podcast in South Africa and Hong Kong, and third in Australia. It is so popular ‘down under’ that Anthony Albanese appeared on it during his re-election campaign last year. The hosts, Alastair ‘Bloodfeast’ Campbell and Roderick ‘Rory’ Stewart, regularly sell out arenas across the country.
The podcast is huge and is making its hosts filthy rich. It regularly hosts prime ministers and presidents. Yet nobody on the right really seems to understand it or to have bothered to examine it properly. The Critic has dismissed it merely as a ‘centrist comfort blanket’. UnHerd writes it off as the preserve of ‘the bourgeousie’. Others have pointed out that the conceit at the heart of the podcast, that the two hosts are meant to represent different political positions, is very often not true. While that last point is certainly correct, even that rather misses the most important thing about The Rest Is Politics — the hosts are thick and bordering on mental illness.
Now obviously, on paper, Alastair Campbell and Rod ‘Rory’ Stewart were once a couple of brainy bairns. Stewart went to school near Slough — quite near Windsor, actually, you might’ve heard of it… Campbell read modern languages at Cambridge and has had a remarkable career as a redtop bruiser, a regime bruiser, and a talking-head bruiser, all while juggling several different bottles of his father’s national drink. Stewart was savvy enough to become an MP, worked his way up into the Cabinet, served competently as Minister of State for Prisons (a rather tough and thankless job) and even had a Master Brew video made about him. I am an anonymous internet troll. They’ve obviously got something I haven’t. But I have listened to hundreds of hours of their podcast, and there are a few things that we must discuss.
Alastair Campbell has become stupid with age and booze. He has two main hobby horses: ‘Climate’ and ‘Brexit Lies’. Whatever the issue du jour, whatever Rory Stewart is trying to talk about, whatever any guest is trying to talk about, whatever a listener’s question is about, there is a decent chance that Campbell, unfamiliar with the matter at hand, will find a way to talk about one of these.
It was the European question, of course, which allowed him to worm his way back into the public realm. He had spent the Coalition years making TV shows about how much he likes alcohol, and how little self-control he has, but nobody really cared and he was very much seen as yesterday’s man, the prophet of a god which was no longer worshipped. In that period, articles about his old boss Tony Blair would discuss how many buy-to-let properties he had. David Cameron was sometimes called ‘the heir to Blair’, but this referred more to his effortless public style than political beliefs. True, the theory of spin developed by Campbell and his good friend Peter Mandelson was adopted by Cameron and Co., an implicit nod to his invention, but the man himself was out in the cold, kept at arm’s length by a Labour Party which (rightly) associated him with the Iraq War.
When the Leave vote triumphed in the Brexit referendum, there were now 16.3 million people who had a reason to be angry, and nowhere to vent their anger. Jeremy Corbyn’s Labour Party had scandalously pledged to respect the referendum result. The Liberal Democrats were obviously too small to stop Brexit on their own. Campbell sniffed out opportunity like a man with some fake leather jackets might sniff out a Times columnist. Sixteen million potential marks, and no other snake-oil in town. He threw himself into the campaign to overturn the result. As other Remainers were wavering in the aftermath of the referendum, he offered himself consistently as an anti-Brexit talking head.
In March 2027, he became editor of the New European, a Remoaner pop-up paper which is somehow still going to this day. Whenever there was a ‘People’s Vote’ march, Campbell was there, multiplying the numbers by ten. It was perhaps at this time that Campbell gained the confidence of his neighbour, Shadow Brexit Secretary Sir Keir Starmer, who would go on to deliberately sabotage his party’s European policy by promising a second referendum without telling Corbyn first.
Why does he enjoy talking about Europe so much? On the one hand, he does seem genuinely to like France and Germany, or at least the idea of France and Germany. He has spent the last few years improving his German to the point where, he claims, he has written columns for German newspapers without the aid of a translator. In answer to a listener’s question about his favourite books, Campbell fondly recalled reading Madame Bovary in the original French as a teenager. Guests on their ‘Leading’ spin-off series include foreign heads of state, such as the then-president of Georgia. Famously they went to Damascus to interview Al-Golani, and to Belgrade to talk to Alexander Vucic. He has cultivated for himself the trappings of a worldly cosmopolitan.
Yet if you scratch the surface, you will not find much underneath. He will organise an hour-long special about the election results in Saxony-Anhalt, and then use it to warn about Trump and Farage. The AfD will try to sell Ukraine out to Russia, just like Trump wants to do. They lie about immigrants, just like Farage. How can Carney show Starmer how to handle Immigration and The Far Right? Which Israeli settler party is most like Reform? To Campbell, the outside world does not really exist beyond a series of shadows cast by Nigel Farage. Perhaps this is really why he is so obsessed with Brexit — deep down, Alastair Campbell is an insecure provincial. He is not so much Malcolm Tucker as he is Beverly Hillbilly.
Likewise his other obsession, climate change. Yes, anthropogenic climate change is real. But for someone who likes to talk about it so much, Alastair Campbell is remarkably misinformed. He repeats uncritically the absurd claim that renewables are cheaper than natural gas, with which even Rory Stewart has to disagree, purely on the basis of being told so by some Labour apparatchik (I think either ‘Steve Rotherham’ or ‘Pat McFadden’, but honestly, after a few hundred hours all these indistinguishable Labour figures just roll into one). Relatedly, he despises AI (although he has never explained why), and has written a blurb for an unofficial publication of the bishop of Rome’s thoughts on the matter.
This blurb offers a great insight into Campbell’s mind and how his intellect has been worn down by decades of tabloid journalism, internet arguments and Bell’s whisky: ‘Beautifully written, hugely significant, speaks truth to power.’ The immortal words were in fact first uttered on the podcast. ‘Speaks truth to power’ is one of a number of stock phrases that Campbell will spit out when he knows he has nothing to say. These catchphrases often appear in groups, such as when he and Stewart were discussing their joint obsession, a ‘middle-powers alliance’.
They spent the heady days of August discussing this in almost every episode. The obvious move for Canada, you see, in light of Trump’s trade war, would not be to wait two years until there is a new president, or to try to negotiate with him. No — it would be to become an ‘associate member’ of the European Union (this doesn’t even exist). They should cut ties with the country which buys 70% of their exports and sells them 60% of their imports, and instead give Brussels lots of money in exchange for being able to ban proper vacuum cleaners and accept thousands of gypsy immigrants.
This issue is like catnip to Stewart and Campbell because it combines their hatred of Trump with their obsession with the EU. And so the idea took on a life of its own, metastasising into this ‘middle powers’ fever dream, an alliance of Canada, Britain, the EU… Japan? ‘Australia?’ ‘Australia, yeah.’ Starmer — sorry, Burnham — would of course have to take the lead on this. For weeks and weeks they talked about this new venture, a magic bullet to stand up to Putin — and Trump! — which would re-affirm the global Rules Based Order and get Britain back at the Heart Of Europe. Burnham, we were told, would be keen. He and Carney both support Everton.
Now that the membership of the alliance had been decided, it was time to consider which ‘values’ it would be based on. So what were these values? Alastair spelled them out for us: ‘Rule of law… decency… being good to people… politics as a force for good… no corruption.’
This is the extent of Campbell’s contributions to what he considers the week’s most important stories, a list of ‘values’ basically consisting of ‘we’re good, they’re bad’, something a child would be embarrassed to turn in. Rory Stewart of course eggs him on. Between the two of them, they have constructed a vast alternate reality, one where the leaders of the Enlightened Countries (the EU, Canada, Australia, and maybe Britain on a provisional basis as long as Farage doesn’t do too well) share all their grand schemes, their private vocabulary, and only to speak about this alliance is as if to make it real. Similarly, in a recent episode, Stewart said he and some ‘expert’ friends were pleasantly surprised that Donald Trump hadn’t cancelled the mid-term elections. The two of them together, egging each other on to higher and higher degrees of derangement, remind me of the two girls in the Parker-Hume murder case. Who knows how dangerous the pair of them could become if our beloved NHS doesn’t intervene?
Of course, those of us who live in the real world know what actually happened this year. Mark Carney went to Strasbourg for a photo-op (stopping along the way to watch Everton beat Wolves in the Carling Cup), but on the EU’s return visit to Montreal last month, the proposals were watered down to ‘an ever closer association of Canada to the EU, short of full membership itself’. If anything comes from this proposal, it will, like the last agreement Canada signed with Brussels, come after years of long negotiations and amount to nothing much at all. Who can forget the endless controversies over cheese in those negotiations? Indeed, such reservations over cheese are one reason why Canada only ratified Britain’s entry into the CPTPP this summer, three years after we signed the accession protocol. If admitting one country to a loose trading partnership took the Canadians three years, does anyone believe they will join the EU in the two years before the next American election? In Alastair Campbell’s one-track mind, the answer is always ‘Brussels’. Perhaps this is because he is so old.
Rory Stewart is a mere 53. For someone so young, he is remarkably narrow-minded and incurious. I suppose that is why he was so at home in the government of Theresa May. True, he appears to have many interests: the power of AI; Ukraine; how to stuff more food down an African child’s gullet. If anything, it is a shame he is no longer in the Commons, where he would be wallowing on Kemi Badenoch’s frontbench like a pig in shit. But if there is one thing that unites these disparate interests, it is this: the belief that Rory Stewart himself is the man to fix them.
He simply cannot conceive that he might be wrong about anything. He refuses correction on any and every topic. He has two very famous gaffes, the first referenced above, when he suggested limiting asylum claims to 0.5% of the population each year (which at the time would have been a more than ten-time increase). This was later sanitised by the Lügenpresse as merely being a matter of a missing zero. The second is worse. He argued that Donald Trump beat Kamala Harris in 2024 because of ‘high turnout from black men’. The fact that black men voted mostly for Kamala Harris, and so an increase in their turnout would always help Harris and hurt Trump, was lost on him. He was roundly mocked for it, and given how much he seemed to be using X, The Everything App at the time, he must’ve read at least one of the many gentle explanations for why he was wrong. Just in case a stray idiot has come across this article and is unsure what I mean, consider this: 78% of black men voted for Harris, versus 21% for Trump. That means, for every five extra black men that turned out, Harris gained 4 votes and Trump gained 1. This would therefore be GOOD for HARRIS and BAD for TRUMP. HARRIS GO UP, TRUMP GO DOWN.
Amazingly, Rory Stewart repeated his claim in an episode which came out two weeks ago on the American mid-term elections. If he is unable to understand basic arithmetic, what can he understand? Pay attention, and you will find the answer is very little indeed. AI is gonna be a real challenge. Data centres, what’s all that about? The sum of his analysis really is things like ‘Starmer takes defence seriously’, followed by ‘John Healey resigning shows that Starmer doesn’t take defence seriously’. There is no point even trying to find a direct quote — just listen to fifteen minutes of any episode of the Rest Is Politics. Nothing comes out of his mouth that isn’t a hairball of received wisdom and cliche. And again, the answer to everything is always to rejoin the EU, stand up to Putin, or some other irrelevant obsession of his.
Let’s finish with Mr Campbell again, since he is by far the worse of the two. In their recent interview with retired tax lawyer Dan Neidle (free on Spotify but paywalled on YouTube, perhaps to contain the following encounter), Mr Neidle made the reasonable point that Scandinavian-style welfare spending would require increasing taxes on middle- and low-earners. This is what they do in Sweden and Denmark and it is pretty uncontroversial among people familiar with these countries that this is the case. Rory Stewart, to his credit, understood this point perfectly fine (perhaps he had it explained to him very slowly beforehand).
Alastair Campbell seemed to as well. He told Dan Neidle that he totally agreed with him, that to reach Scandinavian levels of welfare spending (it was never asked why that would be desirable, on a podcast whose hosts are meant to disagree on things like this, but hey ho!) taxes on rich people would have to go up, and taxes on poor people would have to ‘disappear’.
When Rory Stewart tried to correct Alastair Campbell, he dug in. ‘That’s not what Dan’s saying’, he answered. Unfortunately, it was what Dan was saying. After a brief diversion to discuss Gordon Brown’s working tax credits (I was half-expecting Sure Start centres to get a mention), Rory got a chance to speak again.
‘I think, Alastair, your instinct is that you could get more revenue by taxing just the top of the pyramid, rather tha—’
‘No, I’m not saying that. No, I’m not actually saying that.’
Silence fell.
‘Now, Gordon Brown, when he was Chancellor…’
This article was written by Don Fox, a Pimlico Journal contributor. Have a pitch? Send it to submissions@pimlicojournal.co.uk.
If you enjoyed this article, please consider subscribing. If you are already subscribed, why not upgrade to a paid subscription?

Depressing that these two people can command a big audience. You have to wonder what is wrong with British people when we've been governed by left leaning idiots like this for more than 20 years and everything continues to get considerably worse.
Deserves to be read for this alone. “This blurb offers a great insight into Campbell’s mind and how his intellect has been worn down by decades of tabloid journalism, internet arguments and Bell’s whisky:”