In reviewing Reform’s National Security Review, it is only fair that I first acknowledge that I am a writer, not a politician, and that I am commenting as a writer, not as a politician. I am therefore considering the document as a statement of policy, rather than a piece of political rhetoric. I am not constrained in what I say on national security matters in the same ways that Reform is. For instance, Reform is seriously restricted by the fact that the British and European security establishment has repeatedly — and not entirely without success — attempted to smear them as ‘Russian stooges’. Reform surely noticed that when Ukraine increases in salience, they fall in the polls and the Tories gain; they are eager not to see a repeat of this. Reform is also limited, albeit less fundamentally, by the relationships which they have (and wish to maintain) with the Republican Party in general and Trump World in particular. Open criticism of Trump’s policies, even now that he is crippled politically, remains difficult. Less defensibly, Reform must also remain consistent with their past criticisms, often foolishly short-sighted, of the current Labour Government, who they have attacked for being excessively friendly to China (especially over the farcical spying case).
It is in this context that Reform published their ‘National Security Review’ last week. A PDF of just fourteen pages (and maybe six pages of actual substance), this is not an especially weighty document. Admittedly it is — to give Reform their due — the opening terms of reference for a fuller review. It contains very few new, concrete policy announcements (and despite the short length of the document, also simply repeats a number of old ones); instead, we could say that this document, as a general rule, is a statement of policy direction. There is nothing wrong with this in itself. Perhaps we could say that this is inevitable, given the topic: for instance, it would be foolish to irrevocably lock the country into particular ways of doing war well before Reform had even entered Government. But the result is that a certain wooliness persists throughout, and this is not always merely an inevitable consequence of the topics at hand.

